This is an archive of papers published by the staff and faculty of Fox Chase Cancer Center. For questions about content, please contact Talbot Research Library
Last updated on
Miller SM , Buzaglo JS , Simms SL , Green V , Bales C , Mangan CE , Sedlacek TV
Monitoring styles in women at risk for cervical cancer: Implications for the framing of health-relevant messages
Annals of Behavioral Medicine. 1999 Win;21(1) :27-34
AbstractWe explored the intel action effects of individual attentional style (high versus low monitoring) and the framing of informational messages on the responses of women undergoing diagnostic follow-lip (colposcopy)for precancerons cervical lesions. Prior to the colposcopic procedure, patients (N=76) were randomly assigned to one of three preparatory conditions: (a) Loss-framed message, which emphasized the cost of nonadherence to screening recommendations; (b) cain-framed message, which emphasized the benefit of adherence; and (c) Neurrally-framed message. It was hypothesized that low monitors (who are more positively biased about their health) would show a move adaptive pattern of response to loss-framed information than high monitors (who are more negatively biased about their health). The results of a series of hierarchical multiple regression analyses were consistent with this prediction. Low monitoring was associated with greater knowledge retention (beta = .61, p < .05) and less canceling/ rescheduling of follow-up appointments in the loss condition than in the neutral condition (beta = .82, p < .002). High monitoring, however was associated with greater intrusive ideation when information was presented in the loss-oriented frame as compared to the neutral frame (beta = .99, p < .01). Knowledge retention and screening adherence were not affected by the framing manipulation The differences between high versus low monitors as a function of loss or neutral frame suggest an interaction effect, wherein both the type of framing message and the individual's attentional style lend to distinctive cognitive-affective and behavioral patterns. The findings may have clinical implications for the tailoring of health messages to the individual's signature style.
NotesTimes Cited: 1 English Article 288AC ANN BEHAVIORAL MED